By Hon. Susan V. Hamilton, Former Assistant Secretary and Deputy Commissioner, California Employees’ Compensation Appeals Board
Within the speedy aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic, researchers noticed a lower within the utilization of medical companies in employees’ compensation instances. These reductions didn’t increase any alarms as a result of within the earliest days of the pandemic the USA’s inhabitants was below “stay-at-home” orders, most companies have been “shut down,” and hospitals and ancillary medical services have been working at most capability virtually solely with sufferers contaminated with COVID-19. Elective surgical procedures have been canceled, and the general public was suggested to remain house and isolate in order that medical services may try and handle the overwhelming numbers of COVID-19 sufferers. Nonetheless, this documented important discount in utilization of medical companies in employees’ compensation instances persevered within the three years for the reason that preliminary section of the pandemic, resulting in decrease or steady medical funds per declare. On the similar time, different analysis demonstrated a rise within the frequency of work-related accidents amongst three distinct classes of employees: (1) youthful employees; (2) short-tenured employees; and (3) older employees. To raised inform its understanding of the explanations underlying decrease utilization of medical companies in employees’ compensation instances that has persevered post-pandemic, the Employees Compensation Analysis Institute (WCRI) performed a examine, Traits in Medical Utilization as a Perform of Age and Tenure (Yang, R; Rothkin, Ok; Radeva, E; Dolinschi, R., February 2025, FR-25-02) (https://www.wcrinet.org/reports/trends-in-medical-utilization-as-a-function-of-age-and-tenurea-wcri-flashreport). Whereas the examine’s findings don’t purport to be a crystal-ball forecast for future tendencies within the utilization of medical companies within the employees’ compensation enviornment, they do recommend affordable expectations of medical utilization within the coming years.
The Examine Framework
To deepen understanding of the elements that is likely to be contributing to a decline within the utilization of medical companies in employees’ compensation claims, the examine posed three questions:
First, did medical utilization change in a different way for explicit age or tenure teams, or was there an across-the-board change?
Second, did ranges of medical utilization differ throughout employee age and tenure teams?
Third, did adjustments in age and tenure distribution contribute to the lower seen in medical utilization?
The Methodology
The examine used WCRI’s Detailed Benchmark Analysis Database (DBE), a sturdy database of claims which are fairly consultant of your complete employees’ compensation system and one that features all market segments—i.e., self-insured, voluntary insurance coverage, state funds, and the residual market. From the DBE, claims with an harm date from 10/01/2016 by means of 09/30/2022, and with claims expertise by means of March 31, 2023, have been chosen from 17 states, amounting to greater than 1.1 million claims. The 17 states included within the examine represented all areas of the USA, and the examine used easy averages so that every of the 17 states would depend equally and the most important states (California and Texas) wouldn’t skew the outcomes. The examine excluded COVID-19 claims.
Subsequent, the examine examined 5 sorts of medical service groupings which are generally obtained by injured employees: (1) workplace visits; (2) emergency division companies; (3) surgical companies; (4) post-operative/restoration/remedy; and (5) bodily drugs. Surgical procedure was outlined as “invasive procedures” comparable to arthroscopic shoulder surgical procedure versus ache administration injections. There was no differentiation between surgical companies carried out in a hospital setting versus an ambulatory surgical procedure middle.
The examine used six age groupings as follows: (1) 24 or youthful; (2) 25-34; (3) 35-44; (4) 45-54; (5) 55-64; and (6) 65 and older.
The examine additionally thought-about job tenure, which was outlined as how lengthy the worker had labored for the employer on the time of harm. As a result of so many office accidents occur to new staff, the examine divided the primary yr of employment into three distinct time durations: (1) as much as 3 months; (2) 3 to six months; and (3) 6 to 12 months. The remaining job tenure classes have been 1 to 2 years; 2 to five years; 5 to 10 years; and greater than 10 years.
The Findings
The examine confirmed a sustained lower in utilization of medical companies by injured employees in all age and tenure teams, each within the pandemic and post-pandemic interval of the examine relative to the pre-pandemic interval. A lower in utilization of as much as 7 % was recognized. The examine additionally revealed that youthful employees and employees with shorter job tenure skilled sooner decreases within the utilization of ER companies than different employees.
Subsequent, the examine demonstrated a larger decline within the frequency of ER visits and surgical procedures compared to workplace visits and bodily drugs companies. This decline was roughly 5 % in magnitude concerning ER visits, and roughly 3 % for surgical procedures.
However the lower seen in utilization of ER companies by injured employees through the examine interval, younger-age employees general had a better share of ER visits when in comparison with different age teams.
The examine additionally noticed a better proportion of claims with hospital-based outpatient remedy and non-hospital-based remedy for older employees and employees with longer job tenure. Even so, hospital-based outpatient remedy decreased by roughly 3 to 4 %. Nonetheless, workplace visits and bodily drugs companies declined by solely roughly 2 %.
Decoding the Findings
Whereas the examine confirms a sample of sustained lower within the utilization of all medical companies by injured employees each through the pandemic and post-pandemic interval (by means of March 31, 2023), the examine’s authors have been unable to determine a transparent clarification for the discovering. Slightly, they provide a believable rationale—a shift within the age mixture of the working inhabitants. The examine confirmed that through the interval 2019-2022, the numbers of older employees (45-54) decreased by 2 share factors, whereas the numbers of youthful employees (age 25-34) elevated by related percentages. Since younger-aged employees have much less frequent use of medical companies than their older counterparts, this shift within the numbers of youthful versus older employees possible contributed to the decline in utilization of medical companies through the examine interval.
As to the approximate 5 % decline in ER companies seen through the examine interval, the examine’s authors recommend an identical speculation, though it’s primarily based on job tenure versus age. Throughout the examine interval, the proportion of staff with job tenure of lower than one yr elevated considerably. Total, the share of newly employed employees elevated by 4 % through the examine interval. Since newly employed employees have been proven to be much less frequent customers of ER companies than their longer-tenured counterparts, the shift in direction of a larger variety of newly employed employees possible explains the decline in ER companies.
Despite the fact that youthful employees are much less frequent customers of medical companies than their older counterparts, when medical companies are wanted, youthful employees are likely to rely extra on ER companies than older employees. Prior research have documented the reliance on ER companies by youthful employees. For instance, one examine discovered a better proportion of care offered to younger adults (aged 20-29), larger than for every other age group, happen within the ER. Elements contributing to this discovering embrace the general lack of prevention companies, insufficient transition of care between suppliers, no established major care relationship, and a scarcity of insurance coverage.
The approximate decline of 5 % in surgical procedure companies seen throughout all age teams is probably going associated to the COVID-19 pandemic and its aftereffects. Throughout the pandemic, surgical companies have been extraordinarily restricted. Non-emergent, elective procedures have been placed on maintain or canceled altogether. Staffing shortages, which have persevered to the current day, are contributing elements as effectively. The lower in surgical procedure charges throughout all age teams led to an identical, albeit barely smaller (3-4 %), lower in post-surgical companies.
Despite the fact that workplace visits and bodily drugs are among the many companies mostly offered to injured employees, the charges of such companies additionally declined. Nonetheless, the lower seen (roughly 2 %) is smaller compared to the lower in utilization of ER and surgical companies. Counting on different analysis, the examine’s authors posit that the rise within the frequency of telemedicine workplace visits and bodily drugs companies offered to injured employees throughout and for the reason that inception of the COVID-19 pandemic explains their discovering.
Lastly, the examine’s authors noticed that general, older employees and longer tenured employees have larger utilization of medical companies to handle their work-related accidents. This discovering, the examine’s authors clarify, is in keeping with prior and effectively documented analysis exhibiting that well being care utilization by most of the people will increase with age. Among the many elements related to this phenomenon are longer therapeutic occasions and comorbidities like diabetes. Throughout delayed therapeutic, there could also be extra workplace visits and bodily drugs companies. Certainly, this examine discovered that medical utilization elevated with age for employees’ compensation sufferers.
Is the Decline in Utilization of Medical Companies a Foregone Conclusion?
Readers may wonder if a continued decline within the utilization of medical companies by injured employees past the declines seen within the examine might be anticipated. As to that situation, the examine’s authors don’t make a prediction. Nonetheless, they do recommend what could also be a very powerful consideration in forecasting the long run. The issue that seems to most have an effect on utilization of medical companies by injured employees is the composition of the workforce by age and tenure. Shifts in that distribution seem to contribute to roughly frequent use of medical companies in addition to the kinds and period of these companies.
© Copyright 2025 LexisNexis. All rights reserved.
