An October 2024 accident alongside Toronto’s lakeshore involving an electrical automobile (EV) has raised considerations amongst insurance coverage and authorized consultants following studies a surviving passenger couldn’t free herself from the burning wreck as a result of the crash knocked out the automobile’s electrical methods.
Information studies on the time stated the driving force misplaced management of the automobile, which then crashed and caught hearth. The driving force was killed and a car-wide energy shutdown meant electronically operated door levers failed. Though a handbook door launch existed, the rear-seat passenger who survived the crash couldn’t find it as a result of she wasn’t conversant in the automobile. Unable to open the rear passenger doorways, she was saved when a passing truck driver stopped, broke the EV’s window and helped her escape.
Different EV accident studies from current years present passenger egress was a problem in comparable crashes involving fires within the U.S. and Korea. The crashes have one factor in widespread, notes Matthew Owen, a lawyer at Zarek Taylor Grossman Hanrahan — the automobiles concerned had been all travelling at very excessive speeds.
“Meaning in lots of circumstances when the automobile’s electrics failed, there could also be questions on whether or not its occupants had been lifeless, unconscious or too badly injured to exit the automobile independently, even when inside exit methods had been straightforward to function,” he says.
Then there’s the bizarre nature of fires brought on by the lithium-ion batteries in EVs, which ignite in a course of referred to as thermal runaway and are intensely scorching and tough to place out. Information studies point out the truck driver who assisted in Toronto’s October crash stated the flames rose round six ft within the air. “It’s not the identical as gasoline fires in regular vehicles,” notes Owen.
Associated: Lithium-ion batteries leading to deadly fires – and lawsuits
Whereas the relative novelty of EVs means battery fires and egress issues have been unusual, that’s beginning to change.
“Elevated frequency of occasions whereby power-loss impacts passenger security makes producer arguments concerning the rarity of the occasions harder to face on,” Owen says. “It is a downside staring the producers and the security regulators within the face as a result of it’s not only a one-off.”
He provides that regulators’ reactions will rely upon accident tendencies since their mandates embrace making certain their actions don’t stifle innovation.
“Figuring out whether or not there are sufficient points to query whether or not EVs are protected for Canadian roadways gained’t be a fast course of,” Owen says. “However you’d assume [it] can be one thing on [regulators’] radar, and also you’d assume it might be one thing that’s additionally on the electrical automobile manufacturing [industry’s] radar that these handbook releases must be extra intuitive, apparent and obtainable as a result of there’s a distinctive [fire] threat brought on by lithium-ion batteries.”
In a press release to CU, Transport Canada notes underneath its regulatory framework, “corporations are chargeable for certifying that their automobiles meet Transport Canada’s security necessities by conducting thorough testing of their automobiles and sustaining acceptable take a look at information.”
It provides, “a lot of elements could affect the flexibility of auto occupants to exit any automobile following a high-speed, high-severity crash, together with the automobile’s post-crash situation, and potential occupant’s accidents and mobility, in addition to their cognitive state.”
The place insurance coverage matches in
From an insurance coverage standpoint, many points surrounding most of these EV crashes might fall underneath product legal responsibility, says Adam Mitchell, CEO of Mitch Insurance coverage — regardless that the excessive speeds concerned counsel a sufferer might additionally sue the insurance coverage protection of the individual behind the wheel.
“The court docket would [likely] discover contributory negligence on a pair events [including the automaker because] it wouldn’t have been catastrophic had the doorways been capable of work and let [the passenger] out. In order that litigator might be going to be pointing at a lot of events and their respective insurance coverage corporations and convey them into court docket to allow them to untangle the accusations.”
In response to these claims, automakers would depend on product legal responsibility protection.
“If [the manufacturer] acquired sued, then it might be product legal responsibility protection that might reply. If the [manufacturer] wins…the insurer pays to defend them for the lawsuit, and the automotive just isn’t really present in court docket to be faulty. If the court docket decides they’re not negligent, and it is a one-in-a-million accident, then that’s probably the tip of it,” says Mitchell.
“In the event that they lose, then the insurer pays damages as much as the bounds of the coverage, after which [the manufacturer] will get to resolve if it’s a problem…that [requires] recalling of the automobiles and retrofitting, or the regulator steps in and enforces a recall.”
Within the latter state of affairs, if a producer carries recall insurance coverage protection, that coverage can be triggered.
Associated: Collision claims rise for electric vehicles in Canada
Adoption charges for EVs counsel that if these sorts of accidents proceed to occur, it might affect protection prices for shoppers.
Mitchell factors out that take-all-comers guidelines guarantee drivers gained’t be turned down when making use of for private auto insurance policies.
And, says Owen, “insurers should adapt to dangers posed by a burgeoning know-how. To my thoughts, it begins to turn out to be an underwriting downside. If nothing is finished about these points and incidents preserve occurring, it might result in elevated premiums for electrical automobiles.”
This text is excerpted from the February-March 2025 print version of Canadian Underwriter. Function picture by iStock/SpyroTheDragon
