Mexico’s state-run oil firm, going through heightened scrutiny over a string of lethal accidents at its amenities, set an bold objective early this yr: No extra fatalities.
Simply weeks after saying that focus on, an explosion at a Petroleos Mexicanos oil platform killed one and injured 9. 5 months after that, a refinery fireplace fatally wounded two. In October, a chemical leak on the firm’s solely US facility killed two others and despatched 13 to the hospital. And final week, a gasoline truck accident close to Mexico Metropolis left one useless.
This yr’s deaths are solely the newest in Pemex’s decades-long legacy of deadly accidents. The oil producer leads its friends in employee fatalities and, in 2020, reported extra COVID-related deaths than another firm on this planet. Collectors annoyed by that document have ramped up stress on the corporate, prompting Pemex in March to launch its first-ever sustainability plan – which included a goal of zero employee deaths.
Pemex’s failure to ship on that pledge raises questions on whether or not the world’s most indebted oil firm can proceed to depend on help from buyers. Though Pemex receives money infusions from the federal government – guaranteeing its survival — the corporate is however beholden to bond markets if it seeks to refinance its debt, which stood at round $97 billion on the finish of the third quarter. And the corporate’s lack of ability to fulfill its personal security objectives is more likely to deter US and European buyers with ESG mandates of their very own.
Pemex declined to touch upon this story.
The corporate is going through quite a few investigations and litigation over the US accident at a time when its insurers in Mexico are suspending their protection.
But enhancing Pemex’s security document would require an enormous funding in infrastructure at a time when its refineries are bleeding money.
“Pemex is so under-invested that I’m shocked they haven’t had extra accidents,” stated Carlos Legaspy, chief govt officer of Perception Securities, an investor within the firm. “It’s like a leaky roof, you’re capable of preserve plugging the holes, however not sufficient to get a brand new roof.”
That a few of this yr’s fatalities occurred at a US facility raises additional scrutiny of its security practices, with federal probes and nascent lawsuits revealing particulars concerning the accident that, in Mexico, doubtless wouldn’t be made public.
Worst Leak in 10 Years
The accident on the Deer Park refinery, simply outdoors of Houston, marked Texas’ greatest launch of lethal hydrogen sulfide gasoline in no less than 10 years, in line with a Bloomberg evaluation of state information.
Two Killed After Leak at Texas Oil Refinery Worked for Maintenance Subcontractor
The leak — at a unit used to strip gases from oil merchandise – ran unchecked for an hour, killing two contractors on website and necessitating shelter-in-place orders throughout two communities, in line with the US Chemical Security and Hazard Investigation Board.
Employees injured within the accident are suing Pemex, alleging that the corporate violated its personal security protocols by leaving a valve close to the amine unit unlocked – a sign that the tools had been purged and was prepared for work, in line with Houston legal professional Kurt Arnold, who’s representing the plaintiffs. Actually, the part of pipe that had been emptied and readied for repairs was 5 ft away, in line with the Chemical Security and Hazard Investigation Board, which is investigating the accident.
Ryan Zehl, one other lawyer representing injured employees, stated the ability’s personal alarm system failed, with some contractors solely conscious of the leak after their very own hydrogen sulfide displays went off.
“So then, there was a mass exodus and everyone was operating for his or her lives to flee,” Zehl stated. “It was chaos.”
As soon as the leak was detected, Pemex didn’t make the most of an emergency notification line in a well timed method, delaying first responders, Harris County Commissioner Adrian Garcia stated in a press convention the next day.
“We struggled to get well timed info from Pemex about air monitoring that was occurring at their fence line,” Garcia stated. “Actually, the one message posted by the ability indicated solely routine flaring.”
A consultant for Repcon, the contractor whose worker died within the Deer Park accident, didn’t reply to a number of requests for remark.
Pemex workers and analysts in Mexico say the corporate’s monetary woes set the stage for accidents, with an absence of funding and tradition of cost-cutting making mishaps extra doubtless.
On the Salina Cruz refinery in September, overflowing storm drains containing oily runoff fueled a fireplace that killed two contractors, the plant supervisor stated in a press convention after the incident. And a lethal offshore explosion final yr might need been averted with extra rigorous inspection, folks aware of the matter stated. Pemex had delegated its assessment of the tools to a contractor, Cotemar, that undercut opponents by promising to finish work in a single week reasonably than two, the folks stated.
Cotemar declined to touch upon the bidding course of and on the reason for the incident, however famous that an investigation by Mexico’s legal professional basic discovered neither the corporate nor its workers accountable for the accident.
The frequency and severity of Pemex accidents have led among the firm’s insurance coverage suppliers in Mexico to boost issues about the price of protection. In April, a few of Pemex’s insurers requested the corporate to hold out a assessment of its industrial security technique and, by June, had briefly withdrawn their insurance policies with Pemex, resulting in gaps in insurance coverage protection, in line with inner firm paperwork seen by Bloomberg.
The insurance coverage points shouldn’t have an effect on Pemex’s Deer Park refinery, which at the moment has enough protection for the October accident, Chief Govt Victor Rodriguez stated in a press briefing on Nov. 13. However the firm is going through US penalties amid probes by the Chemical Security and Hazard Investigation Board, Occupational Security and Well being Administration and Texas Fee on Environmental High quality.
“What I see is a number of failures on totally different ranges,” says Faisal Khan, director of the Mary Kay O’Connor Course of Security Middle at Texas A&M. “It’s a failure, A) by way of prevention and, B) by way of management and mitigation.”
{Photograph}: The Pemex refinery in Deer Park, Texas. Photograph credit score: Raquel Natalicchio/Hearst Newspapers/Getty Pictures
Copyright 2024 Bloomberg.
